-
On Differences Between Chinese and Western
Dietary Cultures
Abstract
Diet
is
absolutely
necessary
in
the
life
of
mankind,
and
even
in
the
existence
or
development.
Because
of
the
differences
between
Chinese
and
western
cultural
traditions,
the
Chinese
and
western dietary cultures are different
in concept, target, pattern, attribution and
nature. We study
these
differences
and
then
find
out
the
points
that
can
be
digested,
in
order
to
facilitate
the
communication about cultures between
China and the west.
Taiwan Professor
Zhang Qijun said,
“The old saying,
'Eat, drink, man, woman who wishes greatly'. For
such a standard fair, western
culture
(in particular, modern American culture) can be
said to be male and female culture. But the
Chinese culture can be said to be a
dietary culture.
western lives tend to
men and women, but because of the narrow gender
relations, Chinese people
are dumping
guidance on life in the restaurants. Thus the diet
is rich in culture. Food culture in the
west is not developed enough, but this
underdevelopment itself is the result of the
development of
a culture, so it is
still significant to study the dietary cultures of
Chinese and Western diet. By the
analysis of the differences between
Chinese and western dietary cultures, we can
comprehend the
respective
cultural
traditions
of
China
and
the
west.
And
we
can
also
improve
and
create
the
culture of China.
Key Words
dietary culture; cultural tradition;
differences
摘
要
饮食是
人类生活、
生存与发展的必需,
可是由于中西方文化传统的差异
,
导致了中西方饮食
文化在观念、对象、方式、归属与性质方面
产生了差异,研究这些差异,找出可以融会贯通
的地方,促进中西文化交流。台湾张起钧
教授说过“古语说‘饮食男女人之大欲存焉’
。就
这样的标准而
论,
西方文化
(特别是近代美国式的文化)
可说是男女文化,
而中国可说是一
种饮食文化。
”由于文化传统的缘故,西方人的人生倾向男女关系,而中国人由于对男女关
系的褊狭,
把人生精力倾泄导向于饮食。
由此赋予饮食以丰富
的文化内涵,
虽然饮食文化在
西方不够发达,
< br>但这种不发达本身也是一种文化发展的结果,
所以对中西饮食文化的比较仍
有意义。
通过对中西饮食文化差异的分析,
我
们可以了解中西方各自的文化传统;
同时能对
中国文化进行改善
与创新。
关键词
饮
食文化
;
文化传统
;
< br>差异
Introduction
Once
there
is
a
saying
that
is
eating
well-
deserved
for
human
life”,
so
food
is
an
indispensable condition for the
survival and development of human beings. There
are two desires
in life: one is
feasting them to survive; and another is the lust
of men and women, which can help
the
mankind to carry on the family line. Facing the
two desires, China pays more attention to the
former, while
the
west
tends
to
the
latter.
Such
phenomenon
affects
the cultural
trend.
Diet
is
actually
the contents of our daily
lives, but
why we call
it culture? That is because
the diet has
special
status
in
the
Chinese
culture,
and
it
also
has
a
great
distinction
between
China
and
the
west.
As one of the world ancient nations,
China’s diet has a history almost as long as that
of Chinese
civilization. But
in western countries, ancient thinkers
devoted less attention to the food problem
than the Chinese philosophers did, and
there is even not aware of it to the
the
opposite,
they
recognized
and
interpreted
the world
in
the
perspective
of
the
lust
or
love
of
men
and
women
more.
Whether
the
awareness
of
original
sin
of
Christianity,
Adam
and
Eve
legend,
or
ancient
Greek
philosophy
(such
as
Plato's
dialogue)
who
considered
the
personal
relationships
“love”
as
the
love
of
ontology
of
beauty,
and
regarded
it
as
a reality
thinking
of
philosophy, all these
ideas become the basis of western
philosophers
’ cultural thoughts. All
these
had potential effects on the
development of western culture and westerners’
characters.
Receiving
the
influence
of
respective
cultural
tradition,
the
Chinese
and western
dietary culture
has
had
different
characteristic.
The
differences
in
concepts,
targets,
patterns,
attribution
and
nature
had
reflected
the
different
dietary
culture
in
the
different
state
characteristic;
such
characteristic
has
enriched
the
research
value
of
dietary
culture.
Studying
these
cultural
differences, we can
find
out
a
joint
enhancing
the
communication
between
China
and
the west
through a
comprehensive study of the subject. It may be a
great help to the communication of the
Chinese and western cultures.
I.
Differences in Concepts
First,
the
Chinese
and
western
diet
have
the
differences
that
cannot
be
ignored
in
concepts.
Nobody
will
deny
that
the
Western
diet
is
a
rational
concept,
regardless
of the
color
of
food,
incense,
flavor
and
shape,
but
nutrition
must
be
assured.
It
cares
about
the
intake
of
calories,
vitamins,
protein
and so
on
during
a
day.
Comparing
with
the
Chinese
diet,
western
diet
tastes
stereotyped,
as
simple
as
chewing
the
candle,
but
the
sense
tells
them:
We
must
eat
them
all
because of the nutrition. And then they
put it bluntly, just like refueling machine.
The concept of western diet
is compatible with the whole western philosophy.
Metaphysics is the
main feature of
western philosophy. Such kind of philosophy brings
vitality to western culture, so
the
natural
sciences,
psychology
and
methodology
achieve
a
rapid
development.
In
some
other
aspects, such philosophy proposition is
a significantly obstacle, such as the dietary
culture, which
is the inevitable thing
to drop behind, and just the metaphysics of
methodology marks everywhere.
In
celebration, it stresses tableware, stresses the
staple, stresses the servings, and stresses the
color
and shape mix of raw materials.
But no matter how luxurious the grade is; from Los
Angeles to
New Y
ork, only
one taste of steak, it is no art to speak of. And
as dishes, the chicken is chicken;
steak is steak, even in groups, which
are also conducted in a shallow dish. In a dish of
Muttonchops
cooking
beans,
and
plus
a
few
tablets
of
tomato.
Color
is
on clear,
but
the
tastes
of
the
various
materials are separated, not to
reconcile, and the entire flavor is also simple
and clear.
Chinese
diet
is
a
sense
of
beauty
diet.
When
people
sample
dishes,
they
often say
this
dish
is
and
that
dish
is
delicious
But
if
you
ask what
is meant
by
why
shows that which Chinese
people hanke
r on a diet is just the
“mood” that is difficult for one to say
anything. Even using the
the
The
beauty
pursuit
of
Chinese cuisine
is
clearly
overriding
the
rational
pursuit. This concept
of
diet
is
also
coinciding
with
the
traditional
Chinese
philosophy.
Chinese
philosophy
as
a
representative
of
oriental
philosophy,
its
distinguishing
features
is the
macro,
visual,
vague
and
evasive.
Chinese
cooking
method
is
to
reconcile,
and
the
ultimate
goal
is
to reconcile
out
of
a
beautiful taste. The main stress is
measure and the overall co-ordination. It contains
a wealth of
dialectics of Chinese
philosophy, and all these depend
on the
degree of the wonderful flavor and
harmony of dish. The ever-changing
within degrees decides the changeable of Chinese
food, and it
also decides the
characteristics of Chinese food as well as the
characteristics on each of the chefs.
II. Differences in targets
All
diet
cannot
be
done
without
vegetables.
The word
is
for
the
sound
in
China,
and
it
always has something to do with the
plants. According to a survey of western plants
scholar, there
are
600
varieties
of
vegetables,
six
times
more
than
in
the
west.
In
fact,
the
Chinese
dishes,
vegetable dish is usual food. Meat dish
entered the normal diet only on holidays or higher
living
standards, so since ancient
times, and there was a saying of
language:
fresh
vegetables are mainly to the civilian in general,
only being able to eat meat only in worship.
V
egetarian diet takes the
dominant position in the normal structure.
Chinese
people
consider
the
vegetables
as
the
main
dish;
it
has
inextricably
linked
with
the
advocacy
of
Buddhists.
They
deem
animals
as
and
plants
have
soul.
So,
they
advocate vegetarianism.
Westerners
do
not
seem
to
have
such
a
good
habit.
They
uphold
a
cultural
origin
of
nomadic,
seafaring
nation.
Living
mainly
by
fishing
and
hunting,
collection
and
planting
are
just
the
complement.
There
are
more meat
dishes
in
their
lives.
Feeding,
clothing,
and
using
are
taken
from
the
animals,
and
even
Western
medicine
is
derived
from
animals.
When
the
westerners
introduce
the
diet
characteristics
of
their
countries,
they
always
feel
that
their
diet
is
more
reasonable on the mix of nutrition than
China. The food industry is more developed, such
as cans,
fast
food,
although
the
taste
is
monotonous,
but
it
saves
time,
and
it
also
has
good
nutrition.
Therefore, in
their countries: people are generally healthier
and taller than Chinese, and the people
have
strong
shoulders
and
developed
muscles;
but
Chinese
people
look
short,
their
shoulders
narrow and legs
thin, their skin yellow and their body weak. The
differences between Chinese and
western
food for Westerners to judge the merits of the two
diet is not justified. Mr. Sun Y
at-sen
had profound study of the culture of
food and incisive exposition. In his composing The
Scheme
for
National
Reconstruction,
detailing
the
differences
between
Chinese
and
Western
diet
phenomenon, he concludes:
vegetables and tofu for meal. Such
kinds of food are the most healthy and beneficial
according to
the research of hygienist.
Therefore, the remote people in china, whose diet
are far from meat and
wine, always live
a long life. Also China has a big population, and
Chinese people have enormous
power to
resist disease, but they never try the
non-
diet. “He added:
eat
tofu. Tofu is expected as the real meat in plants,
as it has the nutrition that meat has. It is the
meat
without
toxic
materials.
So
the
Chinese
are
vegetarian
used
to
be
a
custom
without
the
promotion of scholars.
It is also a custom that the European and American
drink thick Wine, eat
meat and fish. So
there was science promotion before and a severe
law later, such as the
United
States Prohibition. And the transfer
will not carry out in a short time.
scientific benefits of Chinese diet and
disadvantages of Western diet.
According to the characteristics of the
significant differences between Chinese and
Western diet
targets,
the
Chinese
character
is
called
the
plant
character,
while
the
Westerners’
is
animal
character. In
response to the cultural behaviors, Westerners
love adventure, exploration, conflict;
but the Chinese people only like to
liv
e banally. According to American
expert on folklore Ruth’s
opinions
on
the
pattern
theory,
Chinese
culture
is
quite
similar
to
the classical world
Apollo-
type
character
and
Westerners’
is
similar
to
the
modern
world
Faust
-type.
Indeed,
the
Westerners such as Americans in the
development of the west, they put the whole family
on the
truck, and go out of the city in
amid rumbling with the supplies. The Chinese
people are always
thinking about
as
home.
But
after
a
few
decades,
the
overseas
Chinese
will
come
back
to
the
mainland
with
crutch to seek their
roots. This concept of return and such human
spirit that can only be said to
cooperate with the accumulation in the
diet. Then it brings cohesiveness to the Chinese
nation and
then makes the human folk
full of energy.
III.
Differences in Dietary Patterns
The
Chinese and Western dietary patterns can be very
different, and these differences affect the
national character. In China, a
celebration, no matter what, there will be only
one form, as sitting
together, sharing
one feast. Banquet uses round table, which has
created a unity of form, which is
courtesy, comity
atmosphere.
Cate
are
in
the center
of
the
table.
It
is
the
objects
for
people
to
appreciate and taste, and it is also an
intermediate of communication. People toast each
other and
share
the
vegetables,
which reflect
the
mutual
respect
between
people
in
the
face
of
the
good
things, also show the
virtues of comity. Although from the health point
of view, this approach has
obvious
deficienc
ies, but it is
in
our national
philosophy
area
of
impact
for future
generations. It
is
helpful
to
facilitate
the
collective
emotional exchanges and consequently
difficult to reform.
The western-style
banquets, although the food and wine are very
important, but in fact they are
just
foil. The core of Banquet is friendship, by the
conversation with the guests who sitting next to
achieve the purpose of recreation. If
making an analogous compare between the recreation
of the
banquets and dancing, it may be
said that the Chinese banquet is like group dance,
and the western
banquet
is
like
men
and
women
dancing.
This
shows
that
communication
purpose
of
Chinese
banquet and western
banquet are very obvious. Only the Chinese banquet
is more popular in the
communion, but
western banquet shows guests reflected in the
friendship between neighbors.
The more
obvious differences between Chinese and western
dietary patterns is buffet dinner which
is popular in the West. This method is
to display all food, and everybody is picking not
fixed in his
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
上一篇:英语4级阅读理解技巧
下一篇:冀教版二年级语文下册单元测试题全册